[Picture story] The Boxer Rebellion: A wound in China's modern history

By Hsu Chung-mao
Historical photo collector, author
Hsu Chung-mao

Share:

ThinkCulture Icon

Get the ThinkCulture Newsletter

Your fortnightly dose of Chinese history, culture and cartoons. Sign up now.

The Boxer Rebellion at the turn of the 20th century goes down in history as proof that if the Chinese are weak, the West will take advantage and China will pay the price. It is a constant reminder to the Chinese of their past humiliations and guides their dealings with the West today. Historical photo collector Hsu Chung-mao shares illustrations of the tumultuous times during that period.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Allied troops attacking Beijing.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Allied troops attacking Beijing.

(All images courtesy of Hsu Chung-mao.)

The group that came to be known as the Boxers (义和团, Yihetuan, lit. Group of Righteousness and Harmony) originated from local militia groups during the reigns of the Xianfeng and Tongzhi emperors. To protect their home and property, these people practised a type of martial arts known as yihequan (义和拳, literally fists of righteousness and harmony), which led to their name.

In 1887, a dispute involving Christian missionaries arose in Shandong, leading to a wave of xenophobia, and the Boxers evolved into an anti-Christian body. Their ideas came from novels such as Investiture of the Gods (《封神榜》), Journey to the West (《西游记》), and Romance of the Three Kingdoms (《三国演义》), while the gods and deities they believed in were characters in supernatural or martial arts/wuxia novels.

In 1895, during the First Sino-Japanese War, the Qing empire was defeated by Japan, its little neighbour to the east. This sent shock waves through the intellectuals in China, who realised that China's modernisation could not be limited to building new factories and weapons. There had to be a fundamental reform within the political, military, and education systems.

So, in 1898, the young Guangxu emperor brought together a group of intellectuals to drive the reform of the country's systems. However, this stoked resistance among the old-timers at court. They went to the Empress Dowager Cixi - who in fact held full administrative powers - and accused the reformists of plotting to overthrow Qing rule. Cixi accepted what they said and put Guangxu under house arrest, and had the reformist leaders killed, ending what came to be known as the Hundred Days' Reform.

The Western powers supported Guangxu's reformists and secretly protected them, arousing Cixi's hatred of Westerners, so that she seized any opportunity for revenge. Yu Xian, the governor of Shandong at the time, figured out Cixi's concerns and secretly encouraged the Boxers to adopt the slogan "Support Qing, Destroy the West" (扶清灭洋), and reject churchgoing Christians.

In 1901, L'illustration published the illustrated newsletters distributed by the Boxers during the Boxer Rebellion with the slogan "Support Qing, Destroy the West" (扶清滅洋). These six images show the deep hatred of foreigners by the Boxers - using pigs and sheep as euphemisms for Westerners, with a fierce detestation of Western religion, which would not be quenched without their complete destruction. The French provided a detailed translation and explanation of the content of these newsletters. These images are not seen in Chinese records, but have been preserved in Western reports.
In 1901, L'illustration published the illustrated newsletters distributed by the Boxers during the Boxer Rebellion with the slogan "Support Qing, Destroy the West" (扶清滅洋). These six images show the deep hatred of foreigners by the Boxers - using pigs and sheep as euphemisms for Westerners, with a fierce detestation of Western religion, which would not be quenched without their complete destruction. The French provided a detailed translation and explanation of the content of these newsletters. These images are not seen in Chinese records, but have been preserved in Western reports.
In 1901, L'illustration published xenophobic material created by the Boxers during the Boxer Rebellion. These images reflect the Boxers' xenophobia, as well as the deep ideological and cultural conflict between China and other countries when Christianity rejected Chinese traditional religious practices.
In 1901, L'illustration published xenophobic material created by the Boxers during the Boxer Rebellion. These images reflect the Boxers' xenophobia, as well as the deep ideological and cultural conflict between China and other countries when Christianity rejected Chinese traditional religious practices.

The Boxers consolidate their power

Ambassadors of various countries put pressure on the Qing court, and Yu Xian was transferred to Beijing. His replacement as Shandong governor was Yuan Shikai, who suppressed the Boxers, so that they gradually shifted their activities to the old Zhili province - a region around today's Hebei, Henan and part of Shandong - which was directly administered by Beijing.

Yu Lu, the viceroy of Zhili, was initially against the Boxers, but changed his attitude when he noticed Cixi's ambiguity. In line with her intentions, he summoned the Boxer leaders and received them with the highest courtesies, and recommended to the court that the Boxers could be of use.

The Boxers started to act without restraint in the area around Zhuozhou and Baoding - wrecking railways, damaging power lines, and killing missionaries and Christians. Officials and military authorities could not stop them, and the situation worsened. Cixi believed the words of sycophants and thought the Boxers were sent by heaven to help China destroy Westerners. She secretly summoned the Boxers to enter Beijing; within about ten days, there were 100,000 of them. On their flags were written slogans such as "Support Qing, Destroy the West" (扶清滅洋), "Doing Justice for Heaven" (替天行道), and "Sacred Fists of Righteousness and Harmony" (义和神拳).

A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxers damaging power lines and poles.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxers damaging power lines and poles.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxers wrecking railways and power lines and killing Westerners.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxers wrecking railways and power lines and killing Westerners.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxers attacking a church and killing missionaries and Christians.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxers attacking a church and killing missionaries and Christians.

Cixi summoned and met the Boxer leaders, and rewarded them. The elites immediately took her lead. Meeting areas for Boxers sprang up in various temples and residential buildings, and the Boxers were given the authority to move freely in and out of the palace, recklessly killing and sacking, sending Beijing into chaos.

On 11 June 1900, the killing of Sugiyama Akira, counsellor of the Japanese legation, escalated the situation. Cixi held several meetings discussing the situation, but on 20 June, the pro-war camp also had German plenipotentiary Clemens August von Ketteler killed. Cixi had no choice but to officially declare war against foreign colonising powers.

A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the German plenipotentiary Clemens August von Ketteler getting killed on the way to the Office for the General Management of Affairs Concerning the Various Countries (Zongli Yamen, 总理衙门), by officers under Zailan, the nephew of the Xianfeng emperor. The incident intensified the conflict between China and other countries, to a point where it all boiled over.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the German plenipotentiary Clemens August von Ketteler getting killed on the way to the Office for the General Management of Affairs Concerning the Various Countries (Zongli Yamen, 总理衙门), by officers under Zailan, the nephew of the Xianfeng emperor. The incident intensified the conflict between China and other countries, to a point where it all boiled over.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows two French officers killed by Qing soldiers. The incursions on China by the powers stirred widespread xenophobia in China, and frictions increased daily.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows two French officers killed by Qing soldiers. The incursions on China by the powers stirred widespread xenophobia in China, and frictions increased daily.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows Qing troops attacking the legation compound of Beijing. On 21 June, Empress Dowager Cixi declared war on the various powers in the name of the Guangxu emperor, immediately sending Beijing into chaos.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows Qing troops attacking the legation compound of Beijing. On 21 June, Empress Dowager Cixi declared war on the various powers in the name of the Guangxu emperor, immediately sending Beijing into chaos.

Lesson from the Boxer Rebellion

At this time, the armies of the various powers had already won the Battle of the Taku/Dagu Forts and also captured Tianjin. However, there was much distrust among them which resulted in a delay in sending troops into Beijing. On 14 August 1900, the Eight-Nation Alliance - Russia, Germany, France, Britain, the US, Japan, Italy, and Austria-Hungary - began to attack Beijing. Cixi and Guangxu fled to Taiyuan, eventually reaching Xi'an.

A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Allied troops attacking the Taku/Dagu Forts. After the Allied troops landed in Dagu, they captured Tianjin and advanced on Beijing with over 16,000 troops.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Allied troops attacking the Taku/Dagu Forts. After the Allied troops landed in Dagu, they captured Tianjin and advanced on Beijing with over 16,000 troops.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the French troops in the Eight-Nation Alliance, advancing towards Beijing.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the French troops in the Eight-Nation Alliance, advancing towards Beijing.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxer Rebellion, having no qualms in depicting the Chinese as monsters and reflecting the ambitions of the various powers in carving up China. British Queen Elizabeth, German leader Otto von Bismarck, and Russian tsar Nicholas II are clearly seen. The image was widely reproduced, and the original is highly valuable.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxer Rebellion, having no qualms in depicting the Chinese as monsters and reflecting the ambitions of the various powers in carving up China. British Queen Elizabeth, German leader Otto von Bismarck, and Russian tsar Nicholas II are clearly seen. The image was widely reproduced, and the original is highly valuable.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Allied generals holding a meeting. The one holding the map is German Allied Supreme Commander Alfred von Waldersee. Germany arrived two months after the Allied troops entered Beijing, and various countries divided Beijing into different areas of occupation.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Allied generals holding a meeting. The one holding the map is German Allied Supreme Commander Alfred von Waldersee. Germany arrived two months after the Allied troops entered Beijing, and various countries divided Beijing into different areas of occupation.

When the Alliance troops entered Beijing, they pillaged and looted, and arrested and executed the Qing officials and Boxer leaders involved in the incidents, in the name of punishing the guilty. On 7 September 1901, the Boxer Protocol was signed. The Qing court had to pay huge indemnities, and was forced to allow foreign powers to station troops in Beijing, in a loss of sovereignty.

What China saw was the Western powers grabbing China's land and resources, and the Western church seducing the Chinese people to abandon their previous religious beliefs and relegating Chinese temples to idol worship, while also grabbing land from farmers.

A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows a fierce fight between the Allied troops and the Boxers.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows a fierce fight between the Allied troops and the Boxers.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows Beijing's imperial city on fire, and the French troops trying to rescue documents from the palace. In reality, the Allied troops looted the city.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows Beijing's imperial city on fire, and the French troops trying to rescue documents from the palace. In reality, the Allied troops looted the city.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Algerian soldiers of the French army leaving Tianjin.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Algerian soldiers of the French army leaving Tianjin.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows Qing troops outside Beijing resisting the attack by the Eight-Nation Alliance.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows Qing troops outside Beijing resisting the attack by the Eight-Nation Alliance.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1901 shows a French victory over Chinese troops.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1901 shows a French victory over Chinese troops.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the capture of a Chinese battery by Russian troops. Russia took advantage of the Boxer Rebellion to occupy northeastern China.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the capture of a Chinese battery by Russian troops. Russia took advantage of the Boxer Rebellion to occupy northeastern China.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Allied troops entering Beijing and rescuing foreigners in the legation compound.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Allied troops entering Beijing and rescuing foreigners in the legation compound.

The Boxer Rebellion had a deep and lasting impact on the Chinese people. It turned China from being proud and confident to being fearful and servile towards foreign countries, while the Qing court lost its legitimacy of government, and a new wave of reformist thinking arose.

The incident stunned China and the world. However, while it had a major impact on China and the West, it meant different things to each side. What the West saw was China's barbaric people attacking the Western church for no reason, killing religious persons and Chinese Christians, as well as Western envoys. What China saw was the Western powers grabbing China's land and resources, and the Western church seducing the Chinese people to abandon their previous religious beliefs and relegating Chinese temples to idol worship, while also grabbing land from farmers. And so, the Boxer Rebellion was an instinctive reaction by the Chinese against this violation by the Western powers.

A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxers destroying churches, and killing foreign missionaries and local churchgoers.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1900 shows the Boxers destroying churches, and killing foreign missionaries and local churchgoers.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1902 shows statesman Li Hongzhang being summoned back to Beijing from Guangzhou, escorted by Russian troops to meet representatives from various countries. Li had earlier objected to the Boxers and was sent to govern Guangdong and Guangxi, but was called back north to handle the aftermath of the incidents.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1902 shows statesman Li Hongzhang being summoned back to Beijing from Guangzhou, escorted by Russian troops to meet representatives from various countries. Li had earlier objected to the Boxers and was sent to govern Guangdong and Guangxi, but was called back north to handle the aftermath of the incidents.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1901 shows Beijing slowly returning to normal after the Boxer Rebellion, with Qing soldiers escorting Westerners on Li Hongzhang's instructions.
A colour supplement of Le Petit Journal from 1901 shows Beijing slowly returning to normal after the Boxer Rebellion, with Qing soldiers escorting Westerners on Li Hongzhang's instructions.
In the early 20th century, a chocolate company released a series of 24 collectible colour cards based on the Boxer Rebellion. Its intention was to portray the Boxer Rebellion as a political and military victory for France over other countries, and the cards were a commemoration of this victory. This image shows Qing troops killing Westerners.
In the early 20th century, a chocolate company released a series of 24 collectible colour cards based on the Boxer Rebellion. Its intention was to portray the Boxer Rebellion as a political and military victory for France over other countries, and the cards were a commemoration of this victory. This image shows Qing troops killing Westerners.
In the early 20th century, a chocolate company released a series of 24 collectible colour cards based on the Boxer Rebellion. This image from the series shows the Boxers killing Qing officials opposed to the group in the General Management of Affairs Concerning the Various Countries (Zongli Yamen, 总理衙门).
In the early 20th century, a chocolate company released a series of 24 collectible colour cards based on the Boxer Rebellion. This image from the series shows the Boxers killing Qing officials opposed to the group in the General Management of Affairs Concerning the Various Countries (Zongli Yamen, 总理衙门).

The Boxer Rebellion was a deep wound in China's modern history, and it came to symbolise a certain spirit, taking on different significance at different times - the resolve of the Chinese to defend their national sovereignty and hit back at bullying by various powers, as well as the consequences of ignorance due to irrational xenophobia and the rejection of science, which would only lead to the country becoming more backward and unable to stand up to imperialist invasion.

Another major question is how much China has to learn from the West in order to reform and strengthen itself. Sun Yat-sen pushed for a Western-style election and representation system, to which the West was sympathetic. But that did not mean the West was going to let go of the resources and benefits it had seized through military means. So, having the same values as the West will not give China an equal international position; only overall national strength can do that.

In short, each time the Western world exerts pressure on China, the Chinese people are reminded of the unhappiness and anger associated with the Boxer Rebellion.

ThinkCulture Icon

Get the ThinkCulture Newsletter

Your fortnightly dose of Chinese history, culture and cartoons. Sign up now.