Will Norway think twice about awarding the Nobel Peace Prize to Hong Kong activists?

04 Feb 2021
politics
Tai Hing Shing
Journalist, Lianhe Zaobao
Translated by Grace Chong
The last time a Nobel Peace Prize was given to a Chinese dissident, China-Norway relations took a great tumble. This year's nominees include Hong Kong's "Father of Democracy", Martin Lee. Tai Hing Shing takes a look at his nomination and that of other Hong Kong activists. How likely are they to win and how high exactly are the stakes involved?
Police officers line up during a protest against what the activists see as excessive police force against protesters during previous demonstrations, near China's Liaison Office, Hong Kong, China, 28 July 2019. (Edgar Su/File Photo/Reuters)

Martin Lee, Hong Kong's "Father of Democracy" and founding chairman of the Democratic Party, has recently been nominated by two Norwegian parliamentarians for the Nobel Peace Prize.*  

But an academic this paper interviewed thinks that Lee is no longer as influential as before in the social movement circle, especially among the younger generation, and thus has little chance of winning the award. 

Hong Kong Free Press reported yesterday that the two parliamentarians who nominated Lee were Mathilde Tybring-Gjedde and Peter Frolich of the Norwegian Conservative Party. They said in a statement that they hoped their move would "be a source of inspiration for the pro-democracy movement in Hong Kong and advocates for freedom around the world".

Martin Lee, known as the "Father of democracy" in Hong Kong, stands in front of the city's skyline during a recent interview in Hong Kong, China, in this undated image. (James Pomfret/Reuters)

According to the report, Tybring-Gjedde noted that in the past 40 years, Lee has pursued every avenue available to him to try and secure the freedom and safety of the Hong Kong people and that he has "devoted his life to the cause". The report further quoted Frolich's remarks that Lee had "fought for a democratic constitution in Hong Kong before and after the 1997 handover" and that he had "worked peacefully for democratic institutions, free elections by universal suffrage, and political and civil rights, even in the face of mounting pressure from mainland China." Frolich added that Lee was an inspiration to those who sought democratic development and transition in Hong Kong and beyond.

However, Lee has always emphasised that he is a firm defender of the "one country, two systems" principle and opposes Hong Kong independence...

Hong Kong's 'Father of Democracy'

Apart from being the founder of the Democratic Party, 82-year-old Lee is a long-time member of the Legislative Council of Hong Kong. He was a member of the Hong Kong Basic Law Drafting Committee and has advocated Hong Kong democracy for nearly four decades. He incurred the ire of Beijing numerous times for his beliefs and ended up with the moniker of Hong Kong's "Father of Democracy". Lee is also an experienced barrister.  

However, Lee has always emphasised that he is a firm defender of the "one country, two systems" principle and opposes Hong Kong independence, calling the laam caau (揽炒, meaning mutual destruction) philosophy of the Hong Kong youths naive. Following the escalation of the 2019-20 Hong Kong protests, he was harshly criticised on Hong Kong social media platforms.   

This file photo taken on 8 November 2016 shows members from the legal sector, including (front, left to right) senior counsel Graham Harris, former lawmaker Martin Lee, senior counsel Gladys Li and solicitor John Clancey, join other lawyers and law students in a silent march in protest at a ruling by China which effectively barred two pro-independence legislators from taking office in Hong Kong. (Anthony Wallace/AFP)

Last April, Lee was arrested for participating in unlawful assemblies. After his release on bail, he said that he did not regret his actions and that he was proud to walk the "democracy road with Hong Kong's excellent young people".  

High stakes

The Nobel Committee announces its winners in October every year. Personalities and groups related to the protests have been nominated multiple times since the outbreak of the protests in 2019. Of note is the nomination of the people of Hong Kong last year by Norwegian parliamentarians which drew stern warnings from Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi.

Additionally, last November, Britain's All-Party Parliamentary Group on Hong Kong also nominated "Grandma Wong" (Alexandra Wong), an elderly protester frequently seen waving a British flag at protests, for the 2021 Nobel Peace Prize. Hong Kong Free Press was also nominated just before the deadline on 31 January.

Protester Alexandra Wong dubbed "Grandma Wong" holds up signs outside China's Liaison Office in Hong Kong on 28 December 2020 calling on China to free a group of Hong Kong democracy activists facing trial in China, after they attempted to flee the territory by speedboat to Taiwan. (Peter Parks/AFP)

Lau Siu-kai, vice president of the Chinese Association of Hong Kong & Macau Studies, told Zaobao in an interview that the bar set for Nobel Peace Prize nominees is not high. Furthermore, there were instances in the past where Western politicians or organisations nominated anti-China activists to achieve their political goals. While Lee's nomination is not surprising, Lee is no longer as influential as he was before in Hong Kong's political arena, especially among the younger generation. Thus Lau does not think that Lee has a high chance of winning the prize.

Lau also noted that the Nobel Committee awarded Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo with the peace prize in 2010, after which China-Norway relations took a nosedive.

"... the Western economy has been badly hit as a result of the pandemic and needs financial support from China, I believe that the Norwegian government will not make the same mistake twice." - Lau Siu-kai, vice president, Chinese Association of Hong Kong & Macau Studies  

Negotiations for a bilateral trade deal were "postponed indefinitely" (only revived much later in 2017), and China had even restricted the import of Norwegian salmon and other products. It was not until 2016 that both countries announced that bilateral relations would be normalised. Having learnt their lesson, the Norwegian government would most likely intervene in the situation if it finds that the Nobel Committee wants to award Lee with the peace prize.

Lau said, "The Norwegian government was already wary of China a decade ago when the latter was not as powerful as it is now. A decade later, China has become significantly stronger. Coupled with the fact that the Western economy has been badly hit as a result of the pandemic and needs financial support from China, I believe that the Norwegian government will not make the same mistake twice."  

Editor's Note:

*A bipartisan group of US congressmen has also nominated the "Hong Kong pro-democracy movement" for the Nobel Peace Prize via a letter sent to the Nobel prize committee. According to a Reuters report, the point was made that "a number of democracy advocates are already in jail, some in exile, and many more awaiting trials where they are expected to be convicted and sentenced". Therefore, the prize would be a way to "honour their bravery and determination that have inspired the world".

Popular This Month
China’s restaurant chains may be biting off more than they can chew overseas

China’s restaurant chains may be biting off more than they can chew overseas

By Caixin Global

Why did Xi Jinping inspect the DF-26 brigade?

Why did Xi Jinping inspect the DF-26 brigade?

By Yu Zeyuan

How AstraZeneca’s China fraud was about more than greed

How AstraZeneca’s China fraud was about more than greed

By Caixin Global

Kishore Mahbubani: Who got Trump elected? The liberals did!

Kishore Mahbubani: Who got Trump elected? The liberals did!

By Kishore Mahbubani

How China will deal with Trump 2.0

How China will deal with Trump 2.0

By Zhu Feng