How is mainland China planning to achieve reunification with Taiwan, when a common history no longer holds the same significance?

By Han Yong Hong
Associate Editor, Zaobao; Editor, Zaobao.com
Han Yong Hong

Share:

Get the ThinkChina newsletter

Insights on China, right in your mailbox. Sign up now.

For Beijing, the anniversary of the 1911 Xinhai Revolution on 10 October is replete with political significance, not least as a reiteration of the Chinese Communist Party's mission and an assertion of its one-China stance. But for Taiwan's younger generation, the revolution and even the history of the Republic of China are fast losing their meaning. How will mainland China communicate its thoughts on cross-strait relations as it commemorates the Xinhai Revolution over the weekend? With such different perspectives on the history, present and future of "China", how is mainland China going to achieve its goal of reunification?
University students display a flag of the Communist Party of China to mark the party's 100th anniversary during an opening ceremony of the new semester in Wuhan, Hubei province, China, on 10 September 2021. (STR/AFP)
University students display a flag of the Communist Party of China to mark the party's 100th anniversary during an opening ceremony of the new semester in Wuhan, Hubei province, China, on 10 September 2021. (STR/AFP)

In two days, it will be the 110th anniversary of the Wuchang Uprising. The nationwide uprising or mutiny that began in Wuchang overthrew the Qing Dynasty within a few months, bringing an end to dynastic rule that had lasted for thousands of years in China and kickstarting the Chinese revolution known as the Xinhai Revolution.

Mainland Chinese officials commemorate the Xinhai Revolution every ten years in a high-profile manner. But on the other side of the Taiwan Strait, the Xinhai Revolution marks the establishment of the Republic of China and the "Double Tenth Day" is celebrated as a national day in Taiwan. To Beijing however, the Republic of China has ceased to exist since the establishment of the People's Republic of China in 1949.  

Beijing's high-profile commemoration of the Xinhai Revolution is a reminder of history but also more importantly a way of asserting its speaking rights and achieving practical political goals.

The Xinhai Revolution has always been held in high regard by Beijing, as it is seen as a historical bond between both sides of the Taiwan Strait. To Beijing, although the revolution did not change the semi-colonial and semi-feudal nature of Chinese society, it initiated a modern national democratic revolution in its real sense and paved the way for China's progress, spreading the ideas of democracy and republicanism.

According to official descriptions, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) regards the cause it fights for as an "extension and development of the 1911 Revolution" and "the current people of China are all successors of the revolutionary cause started by Sun Yat-sen". Since the 1990s of the previous century, mainland Chinese officials have generally maintained these views when evaluating the Xinhai Revolution.

Closely tied with legitimacy and political goals 

Beijing's high-profile commemoration of the Xinhai Revolution is a reminder of history but also more importantly a way of asserting its speaking rights and achieving practical political goals. Emphasising that the CCP continues the cause of the Xinhai Revolution also justifies the legitimacy of the party's leadership, while commemorating the Xinhai Revolution highlights the fact that both sides of the Taiwan Strait belong to "one China".

A man walks on an overpass decorated with Taiwan flags to celebrate the upcoming Double Tenth Day in Taipei, Taiwan, 7 October 2021. (Ann Wang/Reuters)
A man walks on an overpass decorated with Taiwan flags to celebrate the upcoming Double Tenth Day in Taipei, Taiwan, 7 October 2021. (Ann Wang/Reuters)

This weekend, commemorative events will be held on 9 October as usual, a day before the actual anniversary of the historical event. This could be yet another occasion for Chinese President Xi Jinping to start new discussions on cross-strait relations following the 40th anniversary of the issuance of the "Message to Compatriots in Taiwan" in 2019, where an exploration of a "one country, two systems" formula for Taiwan was proposed.   

Taiwanese media United Daily News quoted insider sources saying that Xi will put forward a new statement on Taiwan, which will importantly point towards the basic strategy of strictly adhering to "one country, two systems" and promoting cross-strait reunification in the new era of the mainland. Xi will also make clear his unwavering opposition to Taiwan independence and foreign interference, clearly drawing an absolute red line and expressing his determination and sincerity towards promoting peaceful reunification at the same time.

Keeping a lid on cross-strait tensions  

Beijing's emphasis on opposing Taiwan independence and promoting reunification is not new. When the CCP celebrated its 100th founding anniversary on 1 July, Xi strongly emphasised that "realising China's complete reunification is a historic mission and an unshakable commitment" of the CCP, and that resolute action must be taken to "utterly defeat" any attempt toward Taiwan independence. He also mentioned that China "will never allow any foreign force to bully, oppress, or subjugate" the country.

Chinese President Xi Jinping arrives for a ceremony at the Monument to the People's Heroes on Tiananmen Square to mark Martyrs' Day, in Beijing, China, 30 September 2021. (Carlos Garcia Rawlins/Reuters)
Chinese President Xi Jinping arrives for a ceremony at the Monument to the People's Heroes on Tiananmen Square to mark Martyrs' Day, in Beijing, China, 30 September 2021. (Carlos Garcia Rawlins/Reuters)

Thus, the following three points will be a focal point at the upcoming commemoration of the Xinhai Revolution: one, will Beijing signal an acceleration of reunification, especially a reunification by force? Two, will the "one country, two systems" formula for Taiwan be made clearer, which, from Taiwan's perspective, means that more boundaries will be drawn? Three, what does Beijing think of the present state of cross-strait relations? Will they deal with it urgently?

The cross-strait situation does look tense. Beijing sent a record 150 aircraft into Taiwan's Air Defence Identification Zone over mainland China's recent National Day break. On 6 October, Taiwan's Defence Minister Chiu Kuo-cheng said the current situation with the mainland was "the most serious" he has seen in his more than 40-year military career - Beijing already has the means to invade Taiwan and would be capable of mounting a full-scale invasion of the island by 2025.

A handout photo made available by Taiwan Ministry of National Defense on 2 October 2021 shows a Chinese PLA Shenyang J-16 fighter, following the incursion of 19 Chinese PLA warplanes including 12 J-16 fighters into Taiwan's Air Defence Identification Zone) on 2 October 2021. (Handout/Taiwan Ministry of National Defense)
A handout photo made available by Taiwan Ministry of National Defense on 2 October 2021 shows a Chinese PLA Shenyang J-16 fighter, following the incursion of 19 Chinese PLA warplanes including 12 J-16 fighters into Taiwan's Air Defence Identification Zone) on 2 October 2021. (Handout/Taiwan Ministry of National Defense)

Even the US is nervous. On 7 October, US officials told US media that for at least a year, about two dozen US special-operations unit members have been secretly conducting training for Taiwan's ground forces, while the Marines have been conducting training with local maritime forces.

This news might provoke another reaction from mainland China. While US President Joe Biden has said that he and Chinese President Xi Jinping agreed to abide by the "Taiwan agreement" during their phone conversation in early September, both sides want to change the current situation. Mainland China seeks to push for reunification, while more than once the US has tested or breached the limits, such as sending officials to Taiwan, normalising US-Taiwan exchanges, and US military aircraft landing in Taiwan.

In a congratulatory letter to the incoming Kuomintang chairman Eric Chu on 26 September, Xi wrote: "At present, the situation in the Taiwan Strait is complex and grim." However, this line was omitted from reports by mainland China state media Xinhua, showing that Beijing does not want to worsen hostilities between people on both sides of the Taiwan Strait, and add to the online talk of "military reunification".

In this file photo taken on 17 January 2017 Taiwan special forces personnel walk behind an armoured personnel carrier during an annual military drill in Taichung, central Taiwan. US special operations forces and marines have been secretly training Taiwanese troops for more than one year, risking the ire of China, The Wall Street Journal reported on 7 October 2021. (Sam Yeh/AFP)
In this file photo taken on 17 January 2017 Taiwan special forces personnel walk behind an armoured personnel carrier during an annual military drill in Taichung, central Taiwan. US special operations forces and marines have been secretly training Taiwanese troops for more than one year, risking the ire of China, The Wall Street Journal reported on 7 October 2021. (Sam Yeh/AFP)

Looking at all this, isn't it clear that Beijing is in no hurry to take military action against Taiwan? In 2025, Beijing will be stronger than it is now and the cost of attacking Taiwan will be lower. Only thing is, as the cross-strait issue becomes increasingly internationalised, Beijing will only get more merciless in its condemnation of independence for Taiwan, and its military intimidation will intensify. The recent flights into Taiwan by 150 military aircraft was a response to the joint exercises just north of Taiwan off the southwest coast of Okinawa, involving three aircraft carriers from the US and UK.

The younger generation even rejects the idea of a so-called "Greater China" (大中华), which means that even if mainland China does achieve armed reunification, governance will be a big problem in future.

If the CCP leaders speak more strongly than before at the session on 9 October, it will be another indication that the situation is tougher. If the wording is not particularly strong, it will show that following the phone call between the Chinese and US leaders as well as the meeting between senior officials in Switzerland, Beijing is still confident that the cross-strait situation will not go out of control. And although the cross-strait atmosphere is not the best, the latter case is more likely.

After all, the bigger issue before Beijing is that for the Taiwanese, the Xinhai Revolution and the history of the Republic of China are far removed. The younger generation even rejects the idea of a so-called "Greater China" (大中华), which means that even if mainland China does achieve armed reunification, governance will be a big problem in future. Beijing has probably thought about this too. It would be more feasible for mainland China to use its current advantage to stabilise the current situation before pushing for peaceful reunification.

Get the ThinkChina newsletter

Insights on China, right in your mailbox. Sign up now.